Tuesday, July 13, 2010

"The Most Common brittle star in the world"?? The tropical-global invasion of Ophiactis savignyi!!


Of ALL the living echinoderms (starfish, sea urchins, sea cucumbers, crinoids, etc.), there's one group that has has become numerically dominant, successfully infiltrated MORE nooks, crannies, and little niches than ANY OTHER echinoderm, and probably has MORE species then any other of the living echinoderms..

That group? The BRITTLE STARS (i.e., the ophiuroids)

Some species of brittle stars have a nearly WORLDWIDE distribution. One case in point-one species that famous/infamous echinoderm taxonomist Hubert Lyman Clark called "the most common brittlestar in the world": Ophiactis savignyi!!
Ophiactis savignyi was described back in 1842 and literally occurs in the tropics ALL over the world in the tropical Pacific, Atlantic and Indian Oceans. This includes Hawaii, Egypt, Australia, Africa, Asia and so on.

Its a very tiny species and isn't much better then the tip of a pen!
This species reproduces both sexually and asexually, so when you find them, there's usually a LOT of them...
Its unusual for a brittle star in that it has 6 rays instead of 5. Its a species that is frequently encountered in the coral rubble in tropical aquaria.
The data for this post came from a neat paper by Roy and Sponer (2002) in the Proceedings of the Royal Society of London! who were studying the biogeography and population dynamics of the globally distributed tropical brittle star Ophiactis savignyi...

The authors collected samples of this species from throughout the tropics!!

(redrawn from Fig. 1 in Roy & Sponer)

They then sampled DNA (specifically the COI mitochondrial DNA gene) from each of the sampled specimens indicated above.
The gene chosen is most useful for distinguishing differences (i.e., the divergence) among populations. So, the DNA is used as kind of a "signature" for determining WHERE the specimen (within this single species) came from..

They can then analyze and compare the DNA in order to group or cluster where the "signatures" originated! Bear in mind, that for the most part, the external differences in this widely distributed species are likely very minute if present at all.. So DNA is usually the only way to determine where these specimens came from..
...AND you get a tree that looks like this:
(redrawn from Fig. 2 from Roy & Sponer 2002)

So, what does this tell you?

Well, on the lower part of the tree in bright GREEN is the Atlantic lineage. That is, those specimens sampled that were originally from the western Tropical Atlantic: Florida, Brazil and so on...

The entire remaining tree in red and blue is essentially Indo-Pacific, that is from areas throughout the Indian and Pacific Oceans-Hawaii, South Africa, Sri Lanka (off India), the Philippines, Guam and so on..

BUT WAIT. Is that GREEN I see, lodged up there amongst the RED? There are ATLANTIC specimens that cluster closely with the PACIFIC ones!

In other words, individuals collected from the Atlantic, show essentially NO (or very little) genetic differences with Indo-Pacific specimens. This implies that at some point a population of Atlantic Ophiactis savignyi migrated from the Indo-Pacific region..

They were also able to assess that there was essentially no genetic change over 3 million years!

So, what explains the presence of Atlantic haplotypes among the Indo-Pacific ones???
This suggests that there has been RECENT genetic mixing and long-distance dispersal of these different populations!!

When and HOW could this mixing have happened?? The authors began digesting the results:

How could Atlantic members be dispersed to the Indo-Pacific? Could ocean currents be the mechanism responsible for the pattern?
In most cases, long distance distribution of species, such as this, is usually due to ocean currents moving larvae away from their "home" or natal sites.

Various current hypotheses were considered.

Migration around the tip of Africa (Cape of Good Hope) was rejected because of the cold Benguela current, which would have likely killed the tropical larvae right away.
And the cold Antarctic Counter Current was thought of being similarly too cold to permit the tropical larvae to pass around the tip of Cape Horn to reach the Indo-Pacific!!
(this image from Olelog!)

They further reject either of these "migration paths" because they also don't see parallel patterns in other marine invertebrates with similar distributions.

So what does that leave?? If all of the "conventional" means of dispersal are eliminated? What's left??

Was Ophiactis savignyi artificially introduced to the Indo-Pacific???
After having eliminated currents as a means of transporting the larvae of Ophiactis savignyi, the authors considered additional facts:
1. There is low genetic diversity
2. Ophiactis can divide asexually
3. Ophiactis is VERY widely distributed.

These all suggest colonization/invasion, followed by a rapid and widespread distribution of a species! But how?

The difference among populations is SO recent, they suspect that this is likely the result of HUMAN-mediated transport.

The authors consider that just a SINGLE sponge can contain up to 3000 individuals!
(from the very fine Tide Chaser blog)

Just a SINGLE sponge containing larvae and/or a few adults could have "colonized" the Western Atlantic!! Both of the Atlantic populations could conceivably have been seeded from Indo-Pacific ancestry as recently as the early 19th Century!

They speculate that the ENTIRE presence of this species in the Atlantic could be artificial!!

The authors add further caution to the paper's conclusions that with the ready transportation from ballast water, larvae from outside regions are readily transported to foreign waters, resulting in unforseen ecological impacts.
(from Friday Harbor Labs!-note that it is NOT Ophiactis savignyi!)

I would further add that I have often frequently observed this species in the rubble of aquarium tanks. Its a species you see in many tanks with tropical inhabitants-both Atlantic and Pacific. Ophiactis is small and comes in with the "living rock" and gravel pretty easily..
Here, we discover what was thought to be a natural, widely distributed species-turns out to be the likely possible result of a human-influenced "marine invasion" from a foreign species. Sort of the echinoderm version of the rat or the cockroach.

Ophiuroids GET everywhere.
Who knows how successful and out of hand they'll get??

Thursday, July 8, 2010

Things around the museum-Hawaiian Sea Urchin Art! Vana (sea urchins) on Kapa!

So, to make up for my blog shortcomings this week, I thought I would share something pretty cool that I found lying around the museum! That's one of the great things about places with so much history....always a good chance to find randomly amazing material!

The above scan comes from a bark cloth print of Vana (or wana) which is Hawaiian for "sea urchin".

The actual print is quite large (about 20 x15 inches) and is made from Kapa, a "bark cloth". Based on the tag that accompanies the print:
Kapa is made from the beaten and felted inner white bark of the Wauke tree (Brousonetia papryifera)-(Echinoblog note-this is also called Paper Mulberry). Kapa was also made from the bark of the breadfruit tree. The bark was separated from the stick, and the outer brown bark was scraped off. It was then soaked in the ocean for 10 days. Then beaten with a round beater made from native hardwoods. This was dried in the sun and when enough was obtained it was soaked in fresh water for a day and put under tea and bannana leaves to ferment for 1-2 weeks. next it was beaten with a square beater into a sheet of cloth. After this, it was decorated with natural dyes and perfumed with maile, sandlewood and mokihana.

Dyes used to decorate Tapa cloth are obtained from the root of the Kukui tree, which is the tree of the state of Hawaii. It is mixed with a special red clay called Alae to make a brown, and with black soot to make a black (presumably color). Yellow is made from the juice of the Olena (tumeric root). All of these dyes are recorded as used by the ancient Hawaiians.
The tag notes that the design was for "Vana (aka Wana), symbolic of the sea urchin which lives in the lava rocks along the shore line"... Which immediately made me think of Echinometra-the widespread sea urchin species found in Hawaii and the Indo-Pacific (shown here).
(image from Wikipedia commons)
But a quick check with my buddy John Hoover's guide to Hawaiian Invertebrates "Hawaii's Sea Creatures" (here to see & buy) shows that Wana/Vana seems to applied mainly to diadematid sea urchins, such as Diadema (shown bel0w) or Echinothrix...
(from the great Tide chaser Blog!)
Hmmm...I'm thinking Echinometra is more of a match...but its pretty cool no matter how you look at it!!
And heck..while I'm at it, here's a link to one of my favoritest posts on the Hawaiian (and beyond) Shingle Urchin (Colobocentrotus)!!!

Enjoy!

Wednesday, July 7, 2010

4th of July short week..its SEA URCHIN-SPINY Tropical Videos Today!

Greetings!
Sorry.. NSF grant deadline plus short week, plus other distractions equals Tropical Sea Urchin video heavy Echinoblog this week!

Enjoy!
Fire Urchins from Lembah!



...and even MORE fire urchins



....here's
Astropyga..another but DIFFERENT fire urchin!


And diadematids (not fire urchins) with their fishy friends!

Tuesday, June 29, 2010

The Ecology of Holothuria scabra! The CUKE-SEA GRASS Connection!

Today- SEA CUCUMBER STUFF! yeah, yeah, cukes get all the good stories!

This is based on a new paper (2010) by Wolkenhauer et al. in the Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom which examines the role the tropical Indo-Pacific species Holothuria scabra and its relationship with tropical seagrass beds!

The subject species, Holothuria scabra is a widespread Indo-Pacific species. It occurs in Asia, Australia and Madagascar in the Indian Ocean in sandy, shallow-water, eel grass beds. Presence below indicated by yellow...
(this map from OBIS-here)

Its a pretty neat beast. It can actually BURY itself into the sandy substrate. Presumably, it is this aspect which earns it, the common name the "SANDFISH".
Yes, if you thought "starfish" was bad.."Sandfish" is even worse and will make your broil in your juices!
But what makes, this beast, such a focus of concern is that H. scabra is a widely fished species which has, in some places has seen complete population destruction from overfishing. (here)

This has motivated MANY studies in sea cucumber ecology and biology. Why?

Because when you remove them, WHAT happens to the habitat they're taken from?? WHAT was their ecological role BEFORE they ended up being sauteed with mushroom sauce??
The STUDY
Wolkenhauer et al., undertook their study in Moreton Bay, in south-east Queensland in Australia in 2003 and 2004.
The authors tested the presence/absence/density of H. scabra relative to its surroundings.

They caged areas off and separated places where cukes were either present/excluded/ Or impeded by the cages.
The authors are careful to note that their study was potentially affected by the time of the year and the number of replicate times they performed the study...but the outcome and its impact remains important.


They also surveyed the sea grass species (Cymodocera serrulata) checking biomass, size, dry weight and several other factors relative to the abundance of the sea cucumbers in the caged areas.

The RESULTS

The short version is: Removing sea cucumbers AFFECTS SEA GRASS systems. In the words of the authors: "seagrass systems may suffer in the absence of holothurians..."

Now, for the sake of space, I'm not going to include EVERY little bit of uncertainty and statistical variation in the data but I will boil it down and say that while there is still DOUBT, there is definitely some signal that suggests exclusion of sea cucumbers from an area will affect seagrass productivity. but here are some choice bits...

Losing Seagrass....
Here is their Figure 3, which shows the two experiments showing average seagrass productivity during the 2003 and 2004 experiments. In this particular experiment examining seagrass biomass there has been a significant decrease over the study period when the cucumbes are REMOVED.
So, what is it about sea cucumbers that makes sea grass beds THAT much more productive when cukes are around??

By ingesting all that sediment and sand and burying itself in the sediment, this kicks up all of the good organic food into the water and can knock loose food and nutrients that would be usable by the seagrass bed and other nearby plants and organisms.

Seagrass beds might also be taking advantage of sea cucumber "ammonium excretions" (which some humans would call "pee" but I would not) into the local ecosystem., thus feeding the surrounding plants and animals.

How much affect would this have??

This paper is one of the foundations of understanding how this "nutrient cycle" could work..

As we've seen before, Sea urchin poop is an important force in kelp ecosystems... (click here to see).

Nutrients and Why tiny Algae is important..
Their Figure 4 shows change in benthic microalgal biomass.

Basically, the amount of organic matter present.. clearly increases when sea cucumbers are excluded (EX below).
To quote Egon Spengler "Peter, that would be BAD"

Why? Well, it turns out that with NO holothurians eatin' their algae, bacteria and detritus, you actually see an INCREASE in the certain organic materials.
There are other studies in subtropical settings which show that algae and bacterial production is REDUCED when sea cucumbers are GRAZING. Up to 10 to 40% of bacterial carbon produced in the summer is apparently taken by sea cucumbers.

This is conceivably a HUGE impact on the productivity of a region!!
With the cukes gone, who eats the bacteria????

The full impact of this hasn't been totally explored but just some hypotheticals you may be familiar with-
What happens in your aquarium tank when you've got too much nutrients and bacteria again???? Your nutrient balance is out of whack. Think of your stomach suddenly producing too much gas. Or a lake with too much algae.
Conclusions: What Do We Take Away from This?

There is a logical chain of events/implication from Wolkenhauer's results.

Sea cucumbers are part of the "natural filtration" function that seagrass beds serve in marine ecosystems.

By burying themselves and freeing up the sediment, they encourage other ecological interactions around them which causes the flow of nutrients and so on.

REMOVAL of sea cucumbers from this system through destructive overfishing, could conceivably harm the seagrass bed/seagrass system
      And why save sea grass?

      Well, for one thing, other commercially fished FISH and many other species live there. But they serve to filter nutrients and chemical inputs to the marine environment among other reasons. which can be found at Sea grass Watch.org. But to boil it down: Seagrass beds are ecologically IMPORTANT.

      Removal of just this ONE species, H. scabra showed an impact on the system.

      Could the lowly sea cucumber could potentially be the ecological lynchpin to the ecological health of seagrass beds??

      Thursday, June 24, 2010

      Saturday special Fresh from Japan: A square-shaped Bat Star! & RAZOR STARFISH!!

      BREAKING NEWS!
      Wouldn't it be cool if US news found freakish square shaped starfish newsworthy?
      Patiria pectinifera
      is the Japanese sister species to the Pacific Northwest Patiria miniata.. here, we see the ANN News channel reporting on this "strange" (although its really not that unusual) irregularity!


      Honestly, though? I have no idea what they are saying. If anyone can provide a translation it would be greatly appreciated!!


      and to round out the weekend... here is Japanese super hero Kamen Rider V3 fighting RAZOR STARFISH!!!! (yeah its no Starfish Hitler, but what is?)

      Here's your Friday Starfish Video!

      So, owing to various distractions, including a mild bout of food poisoning this week has been kind of light!

      Here's some Pacific Northwest starfish videos that always seem to be popping up on YouTube!

      I've actually been wondering why it is there's so MANY videos from the Pacific Northwest relative to Australia and New Zealand, which has a comparably diverse fauna. C'mon guys! show me some starfish (or other echinoderm) lovin!!


      1. Dermasterias and the escape response it illicits from Sea anemones. This video escaped me earlier because its listed under "swimming sea anemones" (hmpf!)... I blogified a little bit about this here..


      2. Some Bat Star (Patiria miniata) time lapse!


      3. What happens when you leave Henricia high and dry? It moves back underwater...but you'd never see it...


      4. And here's a nice intro w/ great footage to the Sunflower star (Pycnopodia helianthoides) from the west coast of North America!